Get a Review – review policy
What genres do you review?
We review science-fiction, fantasy, and thrillers. Please note that YA in those genres will be considered but may not be accepted for review.
We do not review religious fiction, children’s fiction, or romance (on that last category, go and see our friends over at Romance Rehab).
What will my review contain?
Your review will be at least 200 words in length. If you rank three stars or higher, the first half (and no more than half) will be a brief synopsis, followed by our impressions of the book. You can see examples of our reviews on the Reviews page.
How do you rate books?
By Rite of Word has six rating levels:
- 5 stars means you were technically perfect, or very nearly, and you wowed us.
- 4 stars means we liked your book, but either weren’t completely wowed, and/or there were some editorial / plot / characterisation issues that impacted the read for us.
- 3 stars means that we thought your book was OK, but there were significant editorial / plot / characterisation issues that impacted our enjoyment of it.
- 2 stars means that while your book did have at least one strong point, overall we didn’t enjoy it.
- 1 star means we found continuous, serious challenges with the book across one or more areas of editorial / plot / characterisation.
- 0 stars (did not finish) – we couldn’t finish your book.
How long does a review take?
It depends on how many review requests we have in, whether we’re happening to our lives, or our lives are happening to us, and quite possibly the alignment of Uranus (you can see our to-read pile, and where your book is in the queue, on the Reviews page).
Usual turnaround is on the order of three months.
Will you review Advanced Reader Copies (ARCs)?
We’re happy to review ARCs, but if you have a very short timeline to publication, please be aware that a review usually takes around 3 months – meaning that if we accept you, we’ll review you, but it may not show up on release day.
Can I request that you only rate me 4 stars or higher?
No. If you submit your book for a By Rite of Word Review, we will post our honest opinion, whatever rank that may turn out to be.
If your review is via Readers’ Favorite, then we adhere to their publication system and your review will only be published if you get 4 stars or higher.
I know I have some editorial issues. Will you please only review me on the story?
No. We will review your book based on all aspects of your writing. If there are technical challenges in your writing that impact the read, that will be reflected in the final rating.
How can I find out if my book was accepted for review?
If your book was accepted for review, its cover (if we can find one) will appear in our ‘To read’ section on the homepage. If you provided an email in the submission form, we will email you if your book is accepted for review.
Who are you people?
Why do I need a review?
Traditional publishers stack up reviews far in advance of a book’s release, which generates excitement and boosts the book’s presence in searches. For independent authors and small presses, that kind of coordinated publicity may not be an affordable luxury. Reviews help your book to get exposure on Amazon, as well as getting you, the author, honest feedback on your work.
What's so special about By Rite of Word?
Our reviews aren’t editorial reviews – this is why we put a disclaimer line at the end of the review on commercial sites. Also, unless the book falls in the ‘did not finish’ category, getting a By Rite of Word review means a reviewer has read your book cover to cover, and the review is their honest opinion.
- No BS: We don’t accept requests from authors to only provide a certain starred rating.
- No ‘bots: All our reviews are written by a real person.
- No costs: By Rite of Word reviews are 100% free.
Get a review
We need a copy of your book in order to review. Either:
- Upload a PDF or doc file in the form, OR
- Mark the ‘Other file types’ option if you cannot provide a PDF or Word manuscript.
We will only respond to review requests in one of the three genres listed in the request form. Please note:
- YA in those genres will be considered but is less likely to be accepted for review.
- We do not review religious fiction, children’s fiction, or romance.
- If you upload anything other than your manuscript file, your submission will be deleted.
If you do not complete the form, your submission will not be considered for review.
By Rite of Word will consider all books submitted for review. However, because we need to leave time for eating and sleeping, we cannot review all the books we receive.
We will accept between one and three submissions per week for review, dependent on our time, the length of the books, etc.
Wait, I want more!
2018 reviews and overview at By Rite of Word! 2018 is the second full year that By Rite of Word has been up and running, and we've been lucky enough to get a lot of great books in and reviewed. As always, the first order of business is to say 'thank you'...read more
Selecting books - the unknown and arcane Probably what a lot of authors and publicists want to know is: just how does a book reviewer go about selecting books? Well, we can't answer for all book reviewers. Some people (lucky sods) can read pretty much full...read more
Man-spreading is annoying. Why do I want to spread the reviews? There's safety in redundancy. Amazon has tweaked its algorithms again, and every breed of author has noticed reviews taken down, even 'verified' ones, which are supposed to be proof against...read more
2017 - it's a wrap! By Rite of Word started up in March 2016, so 2017 is our first full year up and reviewing. (We're a little bit excited about this.) We've had a lot of awesome indie and trad-pub books come in for review, which makes the first order of...read more
Or, why thinking is good for you Complicated books, oh my. We've been seeing a lot of reviews in various spots on the Interwebz recently, saying that a book was complicated, or used UK English (gasp) instead of US English, or used words the reader didn't...read more
Here's the first of the reviewing myths that needs busting: there's a surprising number of people out there who think that a review needs to be a complex essay, analysing every aspect of the author's writing and which classical authors impacted their style. Not so....read more
Final copies - the importance of being finished Or, as the late Terry Pratchett eloquently put it, 'Life is like a sewer; what you get out depends on what you put in.' Because, you know what? We read A LOT of books here are By Rite of Word. Something like ten a month....read more
By Rite of Word - what do we review and how do we rate? A little while ago, we passed our 6-month anniversary here at By Rite of Word. I didn't actually noticed until I counted fingers: I was probably reading. Or writing. Or wondering if there was any way I could do...read more
Blurb in reviews The blurb, the jacket copy, back-cover copy ... call it what you will, most authors have heard of it, and a lot of authors hate having to write it. However, experience with the book writing world indicates it's an important factor in getting a...read more