Oops! It appears that you have disabled your Javascript. In order for you to see this page as it is meant to appear, we ask that you please re-enable your Javascript!
Spread the reviews

Spread the reviews

Man-spreading is annoying. Why do I want to spread the reviews?

There’s safety in redundancy. Amazon has tweaked its algorithms again, and every breed of author has noticed reviews taken down, even ‘verified’ ones, which are supposed to be proof against most Amazon nonsense.

Amazon sees policing farmed reviews, bought reviews, and reviews from people who may know the author, as its business. Unfortunately, it leaves this policing up to computer programs, and as you will know if you’ve ever asked why a review has been removed, you can ask three different customer support people and get three different answers. Basically, no-one but the tech who made the change knows what they intended to achieve, and no-one, including the tech who made the change, knows what that algorithm may do in practice.

In this latest case, no-one’s been able to find out exactly what they were targeting, but a lot of legitimate reviews have gone missing.

Which brings me, slowly yet surely, to my point. Spread your reviews as widely as you can. Do an author a favour and add some redundancy.

Obviously if the author’s still at the stage of trusting that Amazon will do right by them, they may only be on Amazon. Even if an author is still Amazon-exclusive, it might be worth seeing if they’re on Goodreads.

A lot of authors, though, are up in other stores where you may have an account: Smashwords, Barnes&Noble, iTunes, Google Play Books, Waterstones, Kobo…I tend to run a Google search on the book title, and anywhere I have an account and the book is listed, I copy and paste the review in there as well. Just in case Amazon decides that reviews containing the letter ‘e’ are biased, unsafe, immoral, or possibly from your estranged second cousin twice removed’s boyfriend.

2017 at By Rite of Word – it’s a wrap!

2017 at By Rite of Word – it’s a wrap!

2017 – it’s a wrap!

By Rite of Word started up in March 2016, so 2017 is our first full year up and reviewing. (We’re a little bit excited about this.)

We’ve had a lot of awesome indie and trad-pub books come in for review, which makes the first order of business saying ‘thank you’ to the authors willing to share their work with us. No matter if we gave you a 1-star or a 5-star, you wrote a book. The world needs more people writing books. Kudos to you, you crazy one-of-a-kinds – keep going and keep sending us your stuff. We’ll read and review as many as we possibly can.

So, without further ado, what exactly was that voodoo that we did?

Books reviewed

%

5 star reviews

%

4 star reviews

…You noticed that we’re evil, evil sods with our ratings? We mean that bit about ‘Free, honest, and independent’ in our headers. So if you get a 5-star rating, it’s not something we give out in cereal packets. Nor are our 4-stars, so 41% of the books we review getting one indicates some seriously great writing coming into our inbox. Keep it up!

And, because we totally do play favourites…our top picks for each of the genres we review from 2017!

Sci-fi

Our #1 top pick out of 35 great sci-fi reads this year….

Stalk the author in their lair and on Amazon!

Fantasy

Our #1 top pick of the 24 fantasy books we reviewed…

Stalk the author in their lair and on Amazon!

Thriller

And, our #1 winner out of the 15 thrillers we read…

Stalk the author in their lair and on Amazon!

Yep…in case you have a few days off coming and were wondering what to read, grab at least one of those.

Actually, even if you don’t have some time off coming up (although we hope you do…) you should totally treat yourself anyway. Be good to yourselves in 2018!

Why ‘it’s complicated’ isn’t a bad thing

Why ‘it’s complicated’ isn’t a bad thing

Or, why thinking is good for you

Complicated books, oh my. We’ve been seeing a lot of reviews in various spots on the Interwebz recently, saying that a book was complicated, or used UK English (gasp) instead of US English, or used words the reader didn’t know. Usually, the reviewer is knocking off stars for this.

Complicated booksYou know the reaction at By Rite of Word, if a book makes us think, or, better yet, uses a word we don’t already know? We get excited. We go and look shit up. We tell our friends about the cool new word / idea / whatever we found. Yes, this may explain why we read about ten books a month and don’t have many friends.

So, yeah, we’re not big fans of the belief that a book should be written to the lowest likely reading level. We don’t agree that books should confirm to ‘grade-level X‘…unless of course you’re in grade school. The English language has an incredibly rich vocabulary. Over 170,000 words. Tragically, the average native speaker knows between 10,000 and 20,000 of those. There seems to be a growing noise out there that anyone using a word that doesn’t figure in that most common 10 – 20 thousand is, at best, grossly inconsiderate of their less-lettered readers.

Bullshit. Pardon our French, gentle readers.

Using a word the reader doesn’t know is not a crime against humanity. (Providing, at least, that it’s used correctly. If it isn’t, well, then we might join you with tar, feathers, and pitchfork.) Writing is an art form. Making use of the incredibly rich linguistic heritage of English is what writers should be doing. Do you expect painters to stop painting and move to stick figures, because it’s easier to understand?

Thinking is fun. Thinking is, in fact, good for you. While there is certainly a line to be drawn between writers who get so hopelessly mired in their world-building and plots that the story never coalesces into a readable whole, and writers who expect that their readers can follow something a little more complex than ‘Peter and Jane saw a BUTTERFLY!!’, on the whole the point of reading is to think. We read to exercise our imaginations, or to learn. We read to see the world, for the span of a few hours, from a different point of view.

If what you read never challenges you, never makes you think, never evokes an emotional response, never teaches you anything new…what’s the point?

Reviewing Myths

Reviewing Myths

Here’s the first of the reviewing myths that needs busting: there’s a surprising number of people out there who think that a review needs to be a complex essay, analysing every aspect of the author’s writing and which classical authors impacted their style.

Not so. Some people, usually book bloggers who review constantly and so have a lot of experience to draw on, may have a lot to say about a book, and that kind of detailed feedback is a precious thing to any author. However, in general terms, and certainly as far as Amazon’s algorithms go, a simple one-liner carries just as much weight as that professional review. Probably more, if the one-liner also happens to be from a verified purchaser. So don’t hold off leaving a review because you can’t think of a moving eulogy to that character that rocked your world. ‘Couldn’t put it down’ works just fine.

Another of my pet, favourite reviewing myths: The author will hate me forever if I tell them what I really think.

I’ve gotta go with Dr. Seuss here: more or less, them as matter don’t mind, and those who mind don’t matter. Getting negative feedback is part of any type of art. 99.9% of authors are not fragile flowers, and either their shoulders are broad enough to shrug it off, or, in the case of a valid point, to learn from it. The .01% that will try to start a flamedown because someone didn’t get on with their story are going to have very stressful careers. The best thing to do is touch your cap to them and walk on around.

Conversely, the ‘Ah, what’s the point? No one will notice anyway’ feeling is also more common than I’d thought. If you’re reviewing Twilight, maybe yes. If you’re reviewing pretty much anything that hasn’t hit international bestseller status, quite the contrary. The author will notice. Other people wondering whether or not to buy will notice. The website software will notice.

A book review is one place that your opinion, good or bad, cannot fail to make a difference to someone.

 

Final copies

Final copies

Final copies – the importance of being finished

Or, as the late Terry Pratchett eloquently put it, ‘Life is like a sewer; what you get out depends on what you put in.’

Because, you know what? We read A LOT of books here are By Rite of Word. Something like ten a month. We really, really prefer being able to give people good ratings. Not because we think we ‘owe’ anyone four- or five-star ratings. But because it means the book was good, which is easier on us as readers; it looks better for you, the author, not to have two stars, one star, or a DNF flashed all over the Interwebz, and because, on the whole, we’re a fairly conscienceless bunch and we prefer not to have to feel bad for you.

Writing back to us afterwards to say ‘But that wasn’t the final version!’ is not going to alter your review. We’re not going to say ‘Oh, really? Well, that’s OK, then, we’ll give you a five.’ Unfortunately, if you don’t give us your final version to review, your final version is going to cut about as much ice as a soap hacksaw.

So, please. Make it easy for us to give you a good rating. Don’t send us your unedited, non-final effort – because a reviewer is not a beta reader. We’re not going to say ‘thanks for playing and take this away for another six months’ work’; we’re going to review what you give us. If the book you give us still has mark-up in it, includes so many typos it looks as if an executive wrote it in a hurry, and the plot meanders around like a drunk spider – well, that’s exactly what your review is going to say.

Make us (and Sir Terry) happy. Make yourself happy. Make sure what you send us is as good as it can be. We really prefer reading things that wow us, and being able to say nice things about how much the book wowed us.

What do we review and how do we rate? Read all about it!

What do we review and how do we rate? Read all about it!

By Rite of Word – what do we review and how do we rate?

A little while ago, we passed our 6-month anniversary here at By Rite of Word. I didn’t actually noticed until I counted fingers: I was probably reading. Or writing. Or wondering if there was any way I could do both of those and enter NaNoWriMo 2016 and keep my day job. Since no-one else nudged me about it, hopefully they were all reading, too.

Anyway, it seemed like a good time to go and have a look over the last few months, see what we’ve been reviewing the most, exactly how evil we are as per our ratings (pretty darn evil), and share the news with the world.

Turns out, in a little more than 6 months, we’ve posted reviews for 73 books. That averages out at a little over 12 books per month (way to go, bookworms!)

That breaks down to give or take 37% sci-fi, 32% fantasy, 25% thriller, and 6% weird and wild.

And… last but not least, just how evil, mean, and nasty are we? Well, not very. Our most common rating is a 4-star (36% of our reviews).

At the other end of the scale, I’m grateful to say we’ve scored exactly one Did Not Finish – we try really hard not to DNF something unless our hind brains are trying to take control of our hands and gouge our eyes out with a spoon.

However, if you want that 5 star rating, and all that comes with it (probably fan mail, possible drooling on your website pages as the reviewer haunts you for the next book)…well, there’ve only been 18 of those in recorded history.

So, basically – keep up the awesome work, and keep sending it to us!